Client Testimonials for Yoder Barnhart Real Estate Team

Read what others have to say about their experiences working with Yoder Barnhart Real Estate Team to buy or sell their home in Columbus Area. Did you have a great experience working with Yoder Barnhart Real Estate Team? We want to hear about it!

backyard

"I have worked with them on many transactions and have always had a great experience. An incredibly knowledgeable and seasoned team that is always there to help. Real Estate can be a 24/7 job and Nicole and her team are available to help navigate the real estate world. If you are looking for a top agent, look no further!"

1 star 1 star 1 star 1 star1 star

- Adam Baumlein

bedroom

"Excellent service and professionalism by Nicole. Nicole was sincere and helpful from beginning to end. Just the type of person you need when looking for your first home or which every one you are on. She was flexible with timings and availability when I requested to visit a property on the weekend. She gave us her honest view, which helped us in making informative decision. Would definitely recommend."

1 star 1 star 1 star 1 star

- Chris

kitchen

Professional, extremely knowledgeable and one of the best in the business! I’ve used Nicole multiple times and have recommended her constantly to friends over the years. If you need someone who knows the ins and outs of real estate Nicole and her amazing team are it!

1 star 1 star 1 star 1 star1 star

- Molly Moore

We recently purchased a home in Grove City, Ohio. I have to say that our realtor, Nicci Todd, from The Nicole Yoder-Barnhart HER Realtor team, was absolutely amazing! Not only did she make herself available to us day or night, she also connected us with the most recent MLS listings in our respective price range, and desired neighborhood. Nicci, spent many weekends scheduling and showing us numerous homes, even on short notice, until we were able to find just the right one. Nicci, is a consummate professional with a great personality, and is very knowledgable with the current trends in the housing market. A few qualities that really resonated with us was she never tried to show us homes outside of our price range, or houses that didn’t offer the amenities we wanted. She helped us navigate through the entire process of purchasing our new home from start to finish, flawlessly! We can’t thank Nicci Todd, enough for her genuine desire in helping us find our new and final home. If you’re in the market for a new home, I would highly recommend Nicci Todd, from the Nicole Yoder-Barnhart HER Realtor team.
- Monica Taylor-Redding

I just purchased a condominium and Kathleen Hannah with the Yoder Barnhart Team was my Realtor. I have had personal experience in the real estate field, having been a part of it myself years ago. In my opinion, Kathleen Hannah and this team is the only name in real estate that you ever have to remember. As corny as it sounds, I received the kind of attention that you would give to family and close friends. I truly felt that my needs were important and that she honestly wanted me to be comfortable and pleased with my purchase. In addition, this team has access to a loan processor, Sarah Graf, who was incredible. Like Kathleen, Sarah was always accessible and responsive to any and all of my needs. Sarah got me financing at a rate and terms that no one could have matched. On more than one occasion, Sarah went over and beyond to accommodate me. It did not go unnoticed and I am so appreciative. I had no second thoughts throughout the process which was smooth and quick. I never waited for a return call or message from either Kathleen or Sarah. Without them, I would have spent a lot of time spinning my wheels by trying to do any of this on my own. All information was honest and accurate and all commitments were met. Kathleen Hannah is the only Realtor I will ever recommend. Sarah Graf is the only name I will give to anyone who has financial needs.

- Kathleen Lantz
An awesome experience. My wife and I had chosen Nicole and team as our realtor and cannot say enough how they made our transaction so smooth. Communication was on point, and they did all they could to accommodate our needs. Would recommend them in a heart beat.
- Jerome Wallace

We were referred to Nicole after several months working with another team without much luck in selling our Italian Village home despite a very competitive, sellers market. Nicole helped us sell our home within two weeks of working together AND referred us in an agent in South Carolina to help in the buying process (we found and won a home in less than a week too!) Nicole is so on top of things. She is well connected, very organized and VERY GOOD at her job. She was helpful, transparent, responsive, and professional. We are so thankful for her expertise. We highly recommend Nicole. We've already recommended her to a few friends who have since decided to sell their homes too. You wont regret it, she's one of the best in Columbus!

- Dr. Erika Patterson

Nicole and her team are amazing it was the best experience I’ve had. Her team did an awesome job in helping us look and find houses that we would be interested in. Not only did they help us find our dream home but we bought our dream home within only two months of being with her and her team. The financial officer Sarah got us a great deal with the VA loan with zero down and zero closing cost. I highly recommend Nicole and her team for your housing needs.

- Oscar Pueyo

Nicole was great to work with! She's knowledgeable and realistic about the market, and she didn't just say what she thought I wanted to hear. She kept the selling process in perspective, and I appreciate the integrity behind her honesty. I've bought and sold several homes over the years, and I would work with Nicole again.

- Jennifer Whitacre Gardner

She was amazing, caring, and flat out perfect to work with. She listened to what we wanted and worked endlessly to find us our dream home. She went above and beyond getting our open house set up to sell our house and we were able to accept an above asking for offer within 24 hours.

- Zillow User

Nicole was very helpful and knowledgeable  throughout the process, and I felt she really had our best interests in mind contained in all her hard work.

- Torrie3168

We were between buying an existing home or building a new home. We took the leap of faith and re-entered the housing market, by selling our house. Our plans were to sell and then build. During this process, Ron, Nicole & Team made us feel at ease by exploring all our questions, concerns, and scenarios with us. I am a huge advocate of talking through things to make sure we get the best results. Ron's years of experience in the build process, coupled with Nicole's expertise in options that we could explore, helped us make sound decisions. The team works in a pro-active state by anticipating possible hurdles and getting ahead of it to make sure the process was seamless. The buying or selling process of a home is a journey. Make sure you feel comfortable with who you develop that journey with. We are Confident in this team as we continue our journey to build our forever home.

- Peter

Nicole was very helpful and knowledgeable throughout the process, and I felt she really had our best interests in mind contained in all her hard work.

- Torrie

Nicole was very helpful and knowledgeable throughout the process, and I felt she really had our best interests in mind contained in all her hard work.

- Torrie

Nickie was wonderful!! We had issues with the lender and she worked really hard on our behalf so we could close on time. She was right by our side every step of the way. This was our first home purchase and she made it a great experience.

- carteramys82

Nickie was highly responsive and on top of the process from start to finish. She worked with the seller to help us negotiate an acceptable offer. We were not able to visit the property in person prior to purchasing because we live out of state, but Nickie helped us do everything remotely.

- astrouth1

Nicole and her team were great to work with. She explained everything up front and was available during the process to answer my questions. From our initial visit, to our first offer, to being in contract on the home was within days. I highly recommend.

- bparrett75

Two months ago we sat across from Nickie not having a clue what to expect buying are first home. She got us through the process during one of the hottest markets ever. Any time she was just a text or phone call away! Thank you Nickie .

- chew07

The Yoder-Barnhart team is amazing! I have worked with Nicole to sell 2 homes and everything has gone smoothly. The only surprise is how much over asking we receive. Nicole’s team is very attentive and has gone above and beyond for us. Nicole was able to find us a great realtor in SC, as well as assist us with navigating closing on a house in another state. I highly recommend Nicole and her team to anyone buying or selling in the Columbus area.

- Tia Tovinitti

Strongly recommend. Nicole is a great realtor and we were so lucky to work with her and her great team.

- Luke Hatfield

Nickie Butcher has been our realtor for some time now. She is just amazing and such a great fit for us. As real estate investors we always feel confident and open about the homes we decide to move forward with. She is always on top of things and works around the clock to help us make the best deals.

- Jennifer Maguana

Best realtor I have ever worked with. Such an easy transformation. Such a kind and considerate team of people. Always kept informed and such an easy sell.

- Patricia McCall

Nicole and her team have helped us buy and sell a few properties, with the most recent being a new construction for our family. In all of my experiences, Nicole and her team treat each one just as important as the last one. It doesn’t matter the price, big or small, she approaches the opportunity with the utmost professionalism. She’s informative so that you can make the best decision, and helps you navigate where there are difficulties. Nicole and her team have a great reputation and my family trusts her with our home buying needs.

- Beth Berger

Ron, Nicole, and their group were an amazing TEAM to work with. It is clear to me that they utilize the individual strengths of their (8) teammates to make the selling process so smooth and to deliver on their promises. Ron and Nicole were extremely responsive, knowledgeable, and professional in every interaction I had with them. Literally “showing up” and bringing creative ideas and suggestions to help us maximize the value of our home and created a market strategy that delivered an execution that exceeded my expectations. I did not know this team prior to our transaction and I am grateful to have met them. I am happy to recommend them to anyone looking for a strong TEAM to sell their home or represent them on the buy-side.

- Scott Wilkie

Nicole Barnhart and her team were very helpful selling my house. Thanks again!

- William A James Jr

Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and her amazing team handle buying or selling real estate easy for you. We’ve done both. They show you the best of what you want. They keep up with new listings daily. After finding your property, if you’re the buyer, they compare prices, ine up appraisal, financing, testing. If you’re selling, she or her assistants give you updates on what information is due to make the closing process understandable and achievable without delays. They are savvy in all aspects of your deal. I highly recommend these skilled and friendly professionals.

- Ina Jensen

Nicole and her HER team did an amazing job of selling our home quickly! We have nothing but great things to say about her commitment to detail, market knowledge, and overall communication!

- Shannon Stablein

Experience was very smooth, process’s effective and efficient. Relationship professional but friendly. Communication both ways. There are reasons things go good.

- Bill Musser

We used Nicole’s Agency to sell our home after meeting Kathleen Hanna. They worked with us to get the best price possible and I would highly recommend them!

- Renee Gibson

Nicole and the whole team worked tirelessly for us! Every call, every email, every text was answered quickly. We were able to see every house we wanted and they explained the steps to buying very clearly. We are so thankful they were here for us for our first home and we will be proud to have them on our team for our next buying experience.

- Trisha Fowler

Nicole is an outstanding real estate agent with a vast knowledge of the Columbus OH real estate market. Nicole leverages her network and knowledge of the market to help her clients find a perfect home in a very tight real estate market. If you need an agent that will work overtime in your best interest, give Nicole a call.

- Lenny Sisilli

Nicole was phenomenal! My house had been on the market for months without making head way and i had started looking for a cash buyer because i lost hope. Then someone referred Nicole. I was hesitant at first because i thought what is she going to do differently that my current realtor hasn't done, but i gave her a chance and oh boy I'm so glad i did. The house was listed, didn't have to change anything in the house and we were in contract in two days and closed within 30 days. I'm still in shock! She just turned what was starting to be a nightmare into a wonderful surprise.Yes, she is that great! I highly recommend her and her team to you if you want sell your house sold or looking to buy in the shortest amount of time . You won't be disappointed.

- Nancy Antwi

Wow where do I begin.. I’ve used Nicole and her team for many years now. I remember buying my very first home I wanted to see every home on the market in the area I was considering. That is just what we did!! They spent countless hours everyday showing me homes until I found the one. Years later Nicole sold that home for me in a time when the market was really down with no problem. Which allowed Nicole & her team to find another home for me walking into instant equity.. who doesn’t love free money! Nicole and her team again just sold that home for me allowing me to move and live in sunny Florida. I recommend Nicole and her team for all your real estate needs. They are very efficient, knowledgeable, and hassle free. A huge thank you to Nicole and the whole team it’s been a pleasure.

- Gail Stevens
Nicole and Sharon went above beyond any expectations I had during this process. They were available to set up walk through and open houses at almost any hour of the day. They were always prompt with viewing times and gave each house their full attention. I can’t say enough good things about this team. I’ll be referring anybody I know to Nicole, and highly suggest if you are considering her please do.
- Kyle Petko
Have dealt with Nicole Barnhart for years, sold 3 houses with her and did well, excellent experience every time, she performs under pressure like a boss, and set me up with an awesome finance guy, who also saved me money on car/homeowners insurance, a lot of money. She is a super nice person to boot, highly recommend, power team!
- Brian

Nicole and her team have worked with us on three houses in the last year. My husband and I sold our house, bought a condo and worked with Nicole to buy a home for my daughter and her fiancée. It was incredibly stressful year, especially in the market that we have experienced this last year.I cannot say enough positive things about Nicole and her team! She is so steadfast and optimistic. She works hard and looks at many angles to get to a solution. I was impressed with her ability to think outside of the box when we kept losing houses. It took almost a year to find and close on a house for my daughter and her fiancé. We spent so many hours looking at houses, hundreds of houses. They bid on at least 10 and lost them all. Even though they were putting 20% down and making good offers with no contingencies, they just kept losing. Nicole helped us work with a banker who used many creative strategies and adapted those strategies each time the market changed. Between the two of them we were finally able to get a house and my daughter qualified for the 20% tax rebate program. Nicole showed such kindness, grace, and determination to help us win in each sales transaction. I have bought and sold many houses in my lifetime and can say with sincerity Nicole and her team bring something truly special to the table. We are grateful for her help and service.

- Sandy

Nicole and her team were great. I've used them to sell a few homes. They are a full service realtor and you can depend on them to get your home sold in good and bad markets. They take care of their clients!

- Shon Slack

Nicole and her team were wonderful! Thank you for your guidance through the process of selling our home. We appreciate your patience, your dedication, your encouragement, your honesty when things became challenging, your quickness to address issues and also your confidence in selling our home. The Armstrong Family!

- Liliana Armstrong

We loved working with Nicole to sell our home. We were previously working with another Howard Hanna agent who was absolutely atrocious and the switch to Nicole and her team made a HUGE difference. Nicole and her team are so positive and caring and really made me feel safe and supported. Nicole was always updating me on where things were with the house and she was always willing to explain the little details to me and my husband. I highly recommend working with Nicole to buy or sell your home, she makes the process seamless and was a wonderful agent to work with. In a cooling market she worked very hard and got our home sold quickly and efficiently at a price point we were happy with!

- Rupal Patel
Nicole and her team did a phenomenal job of working with us to find the perfect home, make the deal work and sell our current home quickly. We would absolutely recommend her as she definitely goes the extra mile for her clients. We will not work with any other agent! They do a great job of communicating through the process, as well. Highly recommend!!
- Debra McLaughlin
Very helpful and easy to work with Dawn through the entire process. I will definitely use her again in the future.
- Scott Vance

Hello my name is Steven and I am from Dublin Ohio. I had the pleasure of working with the Yoder-Barnhartt team with the Howard Hanna of Hilliard. I listed my house with one of their top agent Ms. Nickie Butcher and my house was sold within 3 weeks for the exact price of asking. They are extremely professional, and very knowledgeable of their work. I highly recommend Ms. Nickie Butcher and the entire team at Yoder-Barnhartt team.

- Steve F
Nicole did a great job making the house hunt and closing as seamless as possible. I highly recommend using Nicole for your future needs! Thanks, Nicole (& Ron)!
- Kody
We just wanted to take the time and give a special thank you to our real estate agent Dawn Tietjen. We had our hopes on a certain house and didn’t think we would be able to get it. But somehow, even with multiple offers, we were able to get our dream home! Dawn was so awesome and helpful throughout the entire process. We our so thankful for your help and will definitely be recommending you to many others in search of a new home.
- Nathan Hay

Dawn Tietjen is a fabulous realtor. She takes great care of her clients. She makes you feel at ease as soon as you meet her. She is very kind and funny. Dawn goes out of her way to meet your needs. I strongly recommend Dawn Tietjen

- Sara

Have worked with Nicole’s team on 3 different occasions. Top notch. Responsive to questions and helped set strategy to sell home.

- Todd Foulis

My family had a wonderful experience with Dawn in buying our first home! She was very understanding of the local market and worked hard for many months to find us exactly what we wanted! She was quick to respond and we really felt like she supported us through the process!

- Jennifer H

Ron and Nicole were the agents who sold our home last March. We decided to build our home and they were extremely helpful, open, transparent, and reliable through the whole process, they really cared about us, understood our needs from the initial consultation, helping us talk through our thoughts and ideas. Both were always available to answer our questions and to show us the support we needed when things got challenging. We appreciate the real estate relationship we have with Ron, that eventually developed into a mentor/guide relationship around the real estate process. He is an excellent communicator who made it really easy to move pass the uncomfortable stages of home building. Highly recommend!

- Dylan Chanthasene

Kathleen sold us our first house 5 years ago, and then helped us sell that house and buy a new one a few months ago. She was very knowledgeable and always available to answer questions and get us in to see houses very quickly. Loved working with her!

- Kelly Richardson

I highly recommend them. The moment you walk into the office they treat you as if you're family. And we found our house within weeks and 6 years later, still loving it!! Thank you guys for your dedication to making sure we find the house that we can call home!

- Michael Robertson

We were referred to Nicole after several months working with another team without much luck in selling our Italian Village home despite a very competitive, sellers market. Nicole helped us sell our home within two weeks of working together AND referred us in an agent in South Carolina to help in the buying process (we found and won a home in less than a week too!) Nicole is so on top of things. She is well connected, very organized and VERY GOOD at her job. She was helpful, transparent, responsive, and professional. We are so thankful for her expertise. We highly recommend Nicole. We've already recommended her to a few friends who have since decided to sell their homes too. You wont regret it, she's one of the best in Columbus!

- Dr. Erika Patterson

Nicole and her team have helped us buy and sell a few properties, with the most recent being a new construction for our family. In all of my experiences, Nicole and her team treat each one just as important as the last one. It doesn’t matter the price, big or small, she approaches the opportunity with the utmost professionalism. She’s informative so that you can make the best decision, and helps you navigate where there are difficulties. Nicole and her team have a great reputation and my family trusts her with our home buying needs.

- Beth Berger

Nicole and her team did a phenomenal job of working with us to find the perfect home, make the deal work and sell our current home quickly. We would absolutely recommend her as she definitely goes the extra mile for her clients. We will not work with any other agent! They do a great job of communicating through the process, as well. Highly recommend!!

- Debra McLaughlin

The Yoder-Barnhart team is amazing! I have worked with Nicole to sell 2 homes and everything has gone smoothly. The only surprise is how much over asking we receive. Nicole’s team is very attentive and has gone above and beyond for us. Nicole was able to find us a great realtor in SC, as well as assist us with navigating closing on a house in another state. I highly recommend Nicole and her team to anyone buying or selling in the Columbus area. 

- Tia Tovinitti

Nicole was great to work with and her expertise is relocation made our experience finding an area so much easier.  Kathleen Hanna is also great.  She went above and beyond to help us in our home process. 

- Stephanie Daquila

My family had a wonderful experience with Dawn in buying our first home! She was very understanding of the local market and worked hard for many months to find us exactly what we wanted! She was quick to respond and we really felt like she supported us through the process!

- Jennifer H

We recently purchased a home in Grove City, Ohio. I have to say that our realtor, Nicci Todd, from The YBTeam, was absolutely amazing! Not only did she make herself available to us day or night, she also connected us with the most recent MLS listings in our respective price range, and desired neighborhood. Nicci, spent many weekends scheduling and showing us numerous homes, even on short notice, until we were able to find just the right one. Nicci, is a consummate professional with a great personality, and is very knowledgable with the current trends in the housing market. A few qualities that really resonated with us was she never tried to show us homes outside of our price range, or houses that didn’t offer the amenities we wanted. She helped us navigate through the entire process of purchasing our new home from start to finish, flawlessly! We can’t thank Nicci Todd, enough for her genuine desire in helping us find our new and final home. If you’re in the market for a new home, I would highly recommend Nicci Todd, from the Nicole Yoder-Barnhart HER Realtor team. 

- Monica

Kathleen was amazing to work with. She sold our home and helped us find a new property that was perfect for our family.

- Eric Gulley

Kathleen was great!! Helped us every step of the way both selling and buying. We love our new house, great location in Hilliard...Kathleen still follows up periodically with us to check our satisfaction.

- Pedro and Dianah

If you're looking to buy a house, Sandy Gould is the way to go! Right off the bat Sandy was absolutely phenomenal and nice. With the market the way it is now, it did take some time and effort, but she was more than happy to find my fiancé and I's forever home. We went to multiple different houses sometimes with our two young children (two under two-years-old!) where she would even help watch them so we could look around. She went above and beyond being just a realtor for my family for which we all appreciate immensely! Between the multiple phone calls, emails, text messages, and the absolute terrible rainstorm we all endured we found it! We found our home, when we were just about to call it quits for a bit, we already toured sixteen homes! Sixteen! The seventeenth home was the charm though. Sandy helped find it to make it ours and now we have it. Our home that we can't wait to raise our children in. It's our forever home that we will forever be thankful for Sandy Gould for helping us find. So, if you're looking to buy a home or even sell a home I 10/10 recommend Sandy.

- McKenzie L & Jason H

Sandy Gould was the best choice of a realtor we could have ever used to sell our house. We had been in the house for 28 years and leaving it was very scary for us, but a necessity. Sandy eliminated any fears we had and was so professional throughout the whole process. She not only had our house sold on the second day it was "live" in the listings, but she got us a lot more money than the original asking price. She made the process so easy for us. She orchestrated all the appointments, set up and handled open houses, found an excellent photographer and had him come take pictures, and she wrote one of the best informational paragraphs regarding a house that I've ever seen. Sandy regularly followed up with us regarding critical steps we needed to take, such as finding a new place to live, hiring movers, and so forth, and always offered to make recommendations for us or help us with our research. She is a wealth of valuable information. I highly recommend Sandy to anyone in the market to sell or buy a house. She is experienced and will quickly get you in or out of a house. 

- Marnie & John Winters

I would like to thank you for all of your help with the selling of the house. You have made the experience smooth and I appreciated all the time you have taken to help me understand the process. Thank you for the constant updates and helping us get through the closing process. Through a rough and crazy time in my life, you were patient and understanding and worked with me and my schedule. I look forward to working with you in the future when it comes to getting a new house!

- Jessica Longnecker

Sandy made selling our home easy and painless! She listened to what we were hoping to get for our home, coached us on the best way to go about getting our home sold, and answered any questions that we may have. Her weekly check-ins were incredibly helpful and it kept us up to date about what was going on. Even though we were home sellers for the first time she made the whole process effortless and painless!

- Curtis L

Thanks to Sandy! I was relocating to another state. I needed a fairly quick turnaround time. I contacted Sandy Gould at the local real estate office. Sandy was timely, efficient, and very professional. Sandy kept me informed throughout the process. I am very satisfied with the deal being done before the year ended. She has exceeded my expectations in every aspect. 

- Alisa P

Nickie Butcher was amazing to work with, she was thorough and diligent throughout the entire process. We would be delighted to work with her again!

- Macala Schweigert

Nicking Butcher was absolutely fantastic! She helped us every step of the way and made sure that we felt comfortable and confident while trying to buy a home! I would absolutely recommend her to anyone!

- Dylan Youngquist

She was very deligant in searching for our house, she was willing to meet us whenever and wherever we needed her to. Nickie showed us 8 houses in 3 different cities, she was able to show us on short notice. She discovered the house that we bought and we absolutely love it! We could not be more happy with the house that we purchased. I would encourage anyone looking for a house to go through Nickie Butcher.

- Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Fairborn, OH.

We had an amazing experience with Nickie selling our previous house and buying a new one! She made the process so smooth and answered all my questions. She helped us in negotiating and making sure we were happy with everything. She was so supportive, and made the whole thing enjoyable! 15/10 recommend Nickie!

- Whalen Vanessa

My husband and I were relocating to the Dublin/London/Marysville area from Convoy, Ohio. She met with us to discuss what exactly we wanted and needed in our next home. She made sure to thoroughly explain what was going on in the market and the process that she follows. Nickie reassured us that she was confident in finding us something rather quickly that we would love. She not only delivered, she made it a smooth and stress free process for us. We will continue to work with her in the future. 10/10 recommend her to literally everyone! We couldn’t be happier!!

- Haleigh Blanton

Nicole and team were extraordinarily professional. She was able to quickly and efficiently help me find the right home. I highly recommend her.

- Christopher Lechner

Dana was amazing in helping us sell our home. As I was going through a very difficult time she was so supportive and caring but still very professional. The whole Howard Hanna group was just amazing!

- Ally

I highly recommend them. The moment you walk into the office they treat you as if you're family. And we found our house within weeks and 6 years later, still loving it!! Thank you guys for your dedication to making sure we find the house that we can call home!

- Michael Robertson
Nicci Todd was absolutely amazing and made the home search and buying process seamless. Through that process, I didn’t just have a realtor on my side, I consider Nicci a friend. She took care of me like family.
- Colleen Thiel

Dawn has been super helpful working around my crazy work schedule. She has gone above and beyond being there for us at all times when we called with questions. Her hard work has helped make a very frustrating search as painless as possible. In the end, I feel she was just as passionate about finding us a home that fit as we were. Could not be happier with her.

- Doug Anderson

Dawn has a huge heart and works so hard for her clients. A phenomenal agent I would recommend to anyone looking for a realtor.

- John Lanz

Nickie took the time to understand our needs and preferences for us to find the perfect home in our ideal location. She is an excellent communicator and always makes herself available to answer questions and provide updates. We highly recommend Nickie to anyone looking for a reliable and dedicated realtor!

- Lily Ng

I recently had the pleasure of working with a knowledgeable and professional realtor and would like to give them a 5-star review. Throughout the entire process, Nickie was always available to answer any questions I had and was very patient in explaining all the details and steps involved in the purchase. Their expertise in the real estate market was invaluable, and she provided me with valuable insights and advice that helped me make informed decisions. In the end, I found the perfect home thanks to the guidance and support of Nickie. I would highly recommend them to anyone in need of a knowledgeable and reliable real estate agent.

- Luke Schroeder

If you’re looking for someone, who is knowledgeable, patient, professional and passionate about getting you into the right home, I would highly recommend Nicci Todd!!! We bought our final home through her, and she was wonderful. She connected us with the most current listings in the desired area we wanted. She would drop everything to attend an open house or showing. She never tried high pressure tactics, and would only find us listing within our price range, and the types of homes we were looking for. If you are a first responder, I would highly recommend Nicci Todd, to take care of your new home purchases!!!

- Steve Redding

Nickie Butcher was my realtor from start to finish! I sold a condo and purchased a home! She was so easy to work with and very responsive! At all points during the process she explained exactly what was happening and helped me understand key decisions! By the end of it all she felt more like a friend to me! She was patient during times that were outside our control and that helped me remain patient as well! She is fantastic and I encourage anyone and everyone to work with Nickie! Thank you so much, Nickie! You absolutely rock!!!

- Garrett Mayhugh

Nickie is a fantastic realtor and made the selling process a breeze. Very knowledgeable, prompt and efficient. I would recommend her to anyone buying or selling.

- Donald Strouth

When looking to purchase my second home, it had been a while since dealing with the ins and outs regarding real estate. I had no realtor and was planning on going through the seller's. Nicci came on recommendations from a family friend. She was very helpful bringing me back up to speed on the whole process and taking care of all my needs and questions. She worked around my busy schedule to accommodate my needs.

- Bought a Single Family home in 2011 in London, OH.

Nicci’s skillset and internal knowledge of the real estate business far exceeds her competition! During my purchasing process Nicci made herself available at a moment’s notice for showings or any questions. I highly recommend Nicci for any of your real estate purchasing or selling needs!!!

- Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2012 in London, OH.

Nicci actually sold my house as well as helped me to purchase my condo. The timing of these transactions needed to be coordinated which involved not just me, but the buyers, sellers and multiple lending institutions. She performed these tasks seamlessly which made my entire experience comfortable and stress free.

- Bought and sold a home in 2013.

We just wanted to take the time and give a special thank you to our real estate agent Dawn Tietjen. We had our hopes on a certain house and didn’t think we would be able to get it. But somehow, even with multiple offers, we were able to get our dream home! Dawn was so awesome and helpful throughout the entire process. We our so thankful for your help and will definitely be recommending you to many others in search of a new home.

- Nathan Russell Lane

Nickie was our realtor, and as a first time homebuyer she made sure we were comfortable throughout the entire process. She really took the time to listen to our needs and wants, and was very responsive and there when we had questions. I would definitely use Nickie again in the future, and highly recommend her to anyone in need of a realtor.

- Amy Zusman

Nicole is a rock star. We worked with her years ago to sell two properties, and we were very happy with her performance. When we brought her into our house to discuss a sale, she was confident that she could sell it within 5 days. We got an offer significantly above asking price in 4 days! The communications were good throughout the process, and she has a top-shelf team working with her. The only negative thing I could say is that we didn’t get the closing documents until the day of the closing, and it would have been helpful to have had them the day before. But the closing went very smoothly in spite of this. Cannot recommend her enough, excellent job.

- Sam G

We were very happy with our experience with Nicole and her team. We had a limited time frame for house hunting in town. I was very satisfied with the guidance and response we received when making an offer from out of state. Nicole went above and beyond to meet our family and allow them to take measurements that we failed to do initially. Thank you to the entire team for a great experience!

- Jennifer Kelp

Nicole and her team made the process of selling my home extremely easy and seamless. You're always somewhat anxious...making the decision to sell your home is a big one. But I always felt I was in good hands with Nicole and that my best interests were of utmost importance. My home sold quickly and everything went smoothly from start to finish! I will gladly recommend the Yoder-Barnhart team to friends, family and neighbors who are buying and selling!

- Rose Karr

Dawn did a great job of listening to our needs as a seller!! The home sold first day on market for a considerable amount over our asking price!! Thank you HH and especially Dawn!!

- R Lance Shook

Sharpest group around. They do what they promise. I would recommend them highly!

- Gary Lyon

The Yoder-Barnhart Team sold my house for me within days of listing! This is the second home I have listed with them and cannot express my gratitude for their efficiency, professionalism and knowledge of what it takes to get a home sold! Nicole Yoder-Barnhart was my agent when purchasing this home and I have been very happy here for over 10 years. I am now moving out of state but would highly recommend her team to anyone looking to buy or sell in the area!

- Karena Wilka

My experience with the Yoder-Barnhart Team was great! Sandy Goldman was my realtor and she did a phenomenal job guiding me through my first time selling my house. The process was so easy and done with prompt attention. Sandy also added personal touches to the process, which really assured me I was in good hands!

- Lauren Payne

Nicole (Nicci) took a hands-on approach with the sale of my late husband's home. She oversaw the entire process from cleaning out the contents of the home, including ordering the dumpsters, to staging the home for sale. She ensured the home sold at a top-dollar, fair market value to a young and growing family. She maintained constant communication giving updates throughout the entire process, made herself available when I had questions, and I felt the closing took place in a timely manner. She took charge from day one and took care of needs I was not even aware of. I highly recommend The Yoder-Barnhart Team for any real estate needs and sincerely thank the team, especially Nicole (Nicci), for their hard work.

- M E Dowler

Dawn was very thorough and thoughtful. She was available within minutes of our texts/calls. I would highly recommend her and the whole real estate team. They go above above and beyond.

- Linda Shell

We recently moved to the area from out of state and after experiencing less than satisfactory interactions with multiple real estate agents, we were thrilled to get connected with Nicole and Ron. Given that we were also expecting the arrival of our first baby (with only 3 months left in the pregnancy), we were desperate to find a home quickly. From the very beginning, Nicole and Ron exhibited a level of professionalism, expertise, and dedication that set them apart (far apart!). They took the time to understand our preferences, needs, and budget, and then curated a list of properties for us. Their knowledge of the local market and amenities in each neighborhood was truly impressive, and they were able to provide valuable insights that guided us in making well-informed decisions. Examples include providing us tours of country clubs, providing HOA materials up front, and explaining the differences in state laws when purchasing real estate in Ohio. As our search progressed, Ron took the lead as our guide. Ron was always available and responsive. He promptly addressed our questions and concerns, and his attention to detail was remarkable, ensuring that every aspect of the home-buying process was smooth and seamless. What truly stood out was Ron’s commitment to advocating for us. He skillfully negotiated on our behalf in a very competitive market, ultimately securing a deal that exceeded our expectations and demonstrated his dedication to getting us the best possible outcome. Even after the purchase was finalized, Ron continued to provide valuable assistance, offering recommendations for local contractors and services as we settled into our new home. Ron and Nicole’s genuine care for our satisfaction truly made us feel like part of a larger real estate family. They even bought our little one a “Welcome Home” outfit! In a competitive and sometimes overwhelming market, Ron and Nicole made the entire process enjoyable and stress-free. Their expertise, professionalism, and personal touch are unparalleled, and we wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone in need of an exceptional realtor team. We are incredibly grateful for their guidance and support in finding our current home. We will continue to use them in the future as needed!

- Erin David

Nicole and her team were fantastic. Very professional and always willing and ready to guide through the selling process. I highly recommend them.

- Nikolas Rubesich

Dawn did an excellent job for us! She was very responsive and made the whole process very smooth. I would highly recommend her for your real estate needs. She was very patient with us finding the right new home. She was able to get both closings scheduled in the same day.

- Rain Boiris

Dawn was amazing! She listed our home and we had four visits on the first day! We had an offer in only 8 days! Dawn was very patient with us by helping us find the right home. She made the whole experience very pleasant and was always quick in responding to our questions. We will definitely use her again and will recommend her to all our friends!

- Iris Darst

We got with these people since we are in Kentucky and our parents are in Ohio that we moved to Hilliard assisted living. It was difficult however everyone that we were back and forward and they have helped us nicely. Highly recommended the Team and the Realtors.

- Bonnie Rings

The team were so helpful from the beginning to the final sale.

- R Hey

Thanks for helping me look for houses and having the patient with me I know sometime it took forever. At the end of the day I end up with a nice and beautiful house thanks again

- Samphorn Chhoy

Kathleen was tremendous in helping us find a house. I could not recommend Kathleen and the Howard Hanna team enough to anybody that is looking to buy a house. She was incredibly helpful in working with our timeline and our budget!

- Connor Polk

Dawn Tietjen did a great job selling my mother-in laws condo for us. She was a real blessing at a difficult time. Got us top dollar and it sold within a few days. Way to go Dawn!!

- Amy Vance

Thank you so much for making a very difficult situation quick and seamless. We couldn’t have done this in record time without the expertise of you and your staff.

- Jessica Rice

Good

- Carmen Pena

Nicole and her team are amazing. I highly recommend if you are buying or selling to contact Nicole and Ron.

- Kathy Hancock

I highly recommend Dawn Tietjen and the entire Yoder Barnhart real estate team! They go above and beyond for their clients. Dawn works so closely with her clients and is a trusted resource for them. She is an amazing Realtor partner as well, always available and always open to new ideas!

- Allie Hager

Nicci Sollars-Todd was a huge help when I was buying a new home. Very responsive to my (many) questions and great at coordinating what needs to be done between all the different parties involved. Overall great to work with!

- Lauren Godfrey

We have sold 2 homes & purchased 3 with Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and I couldn’t imagine going through any other realtor. She is more than a realtor, she becomes family. Your best interest are the core behind everything she does. She is extremely knowledgeable and always comes well prepared with logical advice based on all of the research she has already done and prepared. She is very professional and has an amazing team that is just as knowledgeable and caring as she is. There were countless times we found a listing and wanted to tour it immediately due to the competitive market we were in, and Nicole would have us viewing that home within 24 hours, if not the same day. We refer all of our family and friends to Nicole and her team as they are truly as good as it gets!

- Brandi Goudy

You could not find a better group of folks to sell your home. I was treated like family. They were perfectly respectful of both the business side, and the emotional side, of the process.

Nicole has built a team that is responsive and fun to work with. Kristie was tireless in her commitment to her work on selling my hone, while at the same time accompanying me to showing after showing. I’ve been through this process of selling and buying many times. And Kristie and Nicole, and their support staff, are far and away the BEST I could have hoped for!

- Tin Soldier

Nicole is an eager, enthusiastic young lady who will go the extra mile to get the job done 

- Amy Johnson

- Adam G.

- Connor K.

It was a pleasure working with Nicole and her team. They were prompt and detail oriented. I definitely felt like Nicole had everything under control, and that we could just relax while waiting for our home to sell.

- Janelle Frank

I appreciate Nicole’s willingness to work with us during this difficult time. She was prompt, courteous, and attentive. With many years of real estate experience, has her clients’ best interest at heart.

- Jen Schule

If your looking to buy a New home or just want to know your options this is the realtor for you. I bought my first home with them and it was effortless. And many years later I know they are there for me to help with any realty issues. Contact them you won't be disappointed.

- Tammy Adams

While we appreciated Nicole's kindness, we were extremely disappointed with the state that the house we bought was left in. It took two full days to clean it to a livable state once we moved in. That is honestly unacceptable, especially for a realty team that touts its "perfection." We would not recommend them to anyone in the future.

- Amy McLaughlin

I have worked with them on many transactions and have always had a great experience. An incredibly knowledgeable and seasoned team that is always there to help. Real Estate can be a 24/7 job and Nicole and her team are available to help navigate the real estate world. If you are looking for a top agent, look no further!

- Adam Baumlein

I could not have chosen a better realtor team to help me sell my house. I was referred by a personal friend, and Nicole far exceeded all expectations. Her and her team worked with me closely on every aspect of selling my home, and the entire process went flawlessly. My house was listed on November  1st. and the closing was done on December 11..... 41 days from start to finish! Cannot believe how easy they made the entire process for me, and that was done even with me living 1000 miles away and out of state from the house was that I was selling. I would recommend Nicole to anyone for obvious reasons, and I hope I have the opportunity to work with her again!

- Zillow User

I have worked with Kathleen specifically twice now in home buying. My husband and I are still so new to the whole process. She goes through every detail with us and makes sure we feel absolutely comfortable with each step of the process. I trust her and I appreciate all her advice. We are currently  looking into a new build. She has been there every step of the way including countless trips out to our location. She’s even helped watch our daughter when we were talking with the builder. We can’t ask for someone with more knowledge and patience than her. We only have nice things to say about this team! Thank you for everything!

- K Myers

Six years ago when we were first time home buyers, Nicole's HER office was really helpful. They went out of their way to help us see that we had our dream house. Everyone was nice. We feel very blessed to have them as our realtors!! Would highly recommend them.

- Zillow User

very professional, great knowledge of the area, and easy to work with. great service from the whole team. helped is buy and sell in a difficult market. very appreciative of all their hard work.

- Paul Montesanti

We had an excellent experience with Nicole and her team with both selling our home and building our dream home. She knew the perfect time to sell our home and we sold ok 3 days for over asking!

- Jen Michelle

Penny Smith of the Nicole Yoder-Barnhart group is the most attentive realtor I know. She brings personal touch to each interaction and really takes the time to know and educate her clients. She was relentless in helping us find the right house, in the right neighborhood, in the right price range.  We are first time buyers and she made the process seamless and fun. She is extremely knowledgeable of the industry and is informed on the market. We LOVE our house, but I look forward to the day when I can work with her again to sell my house and upgrade. Penny is amazing! Thank you

- Zillow User

We worked with Nicole and Sharon to sell my mom’s house after she downsized following the unexpected death of my father. They were both sensitive and very helpful to the process of selling a house that was lived in for 30 years. Their process was thorough and they were responsive with our questions.

- Tracy Keyes

Amanda did a fantastic job helping my wife and I purchase our first home. She was patient, knowledgeable, honest, persistent, and caring. She helped to make the process as easy as possible for us, and we would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase.

- Zillow User

Nicole and her team sold our home and the homes of other family members. We were very satisfied with the level of professionalism, knowledge and expertise we experienced.

- Janet Sorrell

Nicole and her HER Team are just perfect to work with. She is so nice and professional. I never have a problem when anyone asks if I have a realtor referral. I will use her for all of my Home selling / buying needs.

- Bailey

If you value professionalism in your realty team, I highly recommend Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and her group. They continue to impress me every year with the level of care they provide to their customers. We bought and sold with YBT in 2011, and have been happy with our experience ever since! Thanks again to everyone there who helped us make our dream possible!

- The Hazzards

Nicole was very helpful in selling my home and buying a new one. She was patient with me during my home search, and gave me tools to find homes as soon as they hit the market. She was always friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about any question I had. It was a pleasure to work with her.

- Beth

I have never worked with an agent as good as Nicole. She took the time to explain everything in complete detail and made me feel good about the purchase. Not only did I have the best in the industry working for me I had someone I trusted to look out for my best interest. She's the best!

- Ryan

I would highly recommend Nicole and her team! We were relocating from Florida to Ohio and relied greatly on her team to help us with our search. When we found a home we were interested in one of her team members were always available to go preview the home for us, take the time to facetime us so we could also view the home remotely and answer our multiple questions on the homes. Upon going into contract they were extremely helpful with us being so far away from working with our lender who was also in Ohio, explaining all phases of the contract process(home inspection, appraisal, warranties available, closing process etc). They helped make a very stressful move much less stressful and I highly recommend them!

- Realtor.com User
From the moment I met Nicole, she was sharp as a tack. I interviewed multiple realtors and was impressed by her 25 year track record and tech savvy. She sold my neighbor’s house $42k above asking and felt confident we could have a similar outcome. Sitting at my dining room table during the initial interview, she produced several “what if we sell at this price” numbers with only a few taps on her phone. The report came via text showing our bottom line after all fees. That was impressive. About a week later we listed the house and held an open house. The showing traffic was unbelievable; a true parade of people. We left for that weekend and came home to 12 offers!! We narrowed them down to an all cash offer, which ended up $56,000 above asking price, along with a backup offer. Two weeks later, we closed on our home and the money was wired to our bank account within fifteen minutes of the closing. Again, impressive.
Now some might argue that the market was the reason for the success, and it did contribute, but I believe that Nicole did many things that impacted the outcome and the higher price. I might mention up front that during this sales process, she experienced the loss of her mother and yet not a single thing fell through the crack. Her team was solid, always available and helpful during her personal tragedy. It’s hard to find the kind of service they delivered. Nicole also worked with our top offers to pull the best terms out of all the offers. This meant our buyers increased the offering price and provided better terms. Ultimately, our buyers let us rent back our home and reduced the cost of rent with her savvy negotiation.
There was a moment early in the process where we had a change of heart about selling, totally because we feared we wouldn’t find a place to go. Nicole stayed steady and executed our decision not to sell, taking our home off the “coming soon” market and cancelling our showings. When we came back a day later and said, “We are facing the fear let’s sell,” she worked hard to line up showings once again. No one wants to do the work twice, and it feels crummy to have a seller do that, but she didn’t show a shred of negative emotion. She just did the job.
Compared to some past experiences with realtors, I can say the interactions were straight forward, didn’t feel manipulative and exceeded my high performance standards. I highly recommend Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and her team.
- Sandy Blanquera

The Nicole Yoder-Barnhart team was outstanding to work with. We needed to sell our home quickly and efficiently and they did just that for us. They were super helpful throughout the process and there was never a lack in communication. We worked with Nicci specifically the most and she was so wonderful! It is nice to work with a team of people who really know what they are doing and do their jobs well. I would highly recommend if you are in need to buy or sell your property.

- Hannah Beth

Professional, extremely knowledgeable and one of the best in the business! I’ve used Nicole multiple times and have recommended her constantly to friends over the years. If you need someone who knows the ins and outs of real estate Nicole and her amazing team are it!

- Molly Moore

I am very pleased with the services provided. Nicole and her team, specifically Sharon Wholaver, were very understanding and proactive in seeing the sale of our home to completion.

- Courtney Taylor

What can I say about Nicole? Patient, loyal, experienced in this crazy buying/selling of a home world. Nicole has been very understanding with us and what we wanted, how much we could work with and what area we wanted to stay in. I would recommend her to family and friends. Nicole's team was also very helpful in communicating the final details to us and getting times set up as well. Thank you very much Nicole!

- Kelly Moore & Terrance Roddy

We have worked with Nicole and team for our last 3 home purchases! She gets the job done and looks out for her client! We can't thank them enough for everything! We love our new home!

- Melissa Robinette

I have worked with Nicole for the last 20 years. I have bought and sold houses with her and I have nothing but good things to say about her and her team.

- Mike

Our opinion of Nicole and her team hasn't changed in 4 years since Julie sold us our current home. Julie Barnhart found what we wanted at a fabulous price and worked with us the whole way. She felt like family! We are happy here and plan to stay the rest of our lives. Thanks, Yoder-Barnhart  team!

-Ed and Gina Lightle

- Lugenia Lightle

Nicole and her team were impressive with their local knowledge, and more importantly their abilities to market the propoerty successfully. Please do not hesitate to utilize her team, could have not completed this sale/processes without her assistance/support!

- Zillow User

Our first meeting with Nicole, she said she was going to make us homeless. She did. We did an open house the first week listed and had 2 offers that day!! Then, game on to find a new house. Nicole and her team helped us learn about buying a foreclosure and the in and outs of the experience. We  did find a house and have been in it 9 years. Nicole and her team helped our friends sell and buy a new home and most recently helped my parents sell their home. Highly recommended

- Zillow User

Nicole sold our house in record time and saved us soooo much on our new build! She is so well-connected and knowledgeable. Everyone I recommend her to is thrilled with her work. Finally, a realtor who gets things done and goes above and beyond!

- Zillow User

Nicole and her team sold our home in less than 1 week AND helped us to buy our dream home! They are all very professional, knowledgable, and very quick to respond to any question that you have. Renee and Sharon helped make the closing process a breeze!! I would highly recommend Nicole and her team  to anyone buying and/or selling a home!!!!

- Zillow User

I have worked with both Nicole and Penny Smith. They are both professional and are very knowledgeable about the industry. Penny Smith has been amazing with us in our search for the perfect house.

- Zillow User

We were referred to Nicole to help us locate a home to purchase after moving from PA to the central Ohio area. From my initial contact with her, she was responsive and very knowledgeable about the area. I always felt she was giving us her full attention even though I know we were not her only  clients. I would definitely recommend.

- Zillow User

Nicole and her team are great. They do a great job of getting your house information out on the market. When we sold our first house the first realtor barely had any buyers come through. We switched to Nicole and her team had multiple buyers in and had the house sold in no time. Same experience  with the sell of our investment property. She will be our first call for any future realty needs

- Zillow User

Nicole helped us keep our sanity in a crazy real estate market with her expertise and her level-headed advising. We had total confidence in her experience and the knowledge she brought to the process was invaluable.

- Kristin

I could not have chosen a better realtor team to help me sell my house. I was referred by a personal friend, and Nicole far exceeded all expectations. Her and her team worked with me closely on every aspect of selling my home, and the entire process went flawlessly. My house was listed on November 1st. and the closing was done on December 11..... 41 days from start to finish! Cannot believe how easy they made the entire process for me, and that was done even with me living 1000 miles away and out of state from the house was that I was selling. I would recommend Nicole to anyone for obvious reasons, and I hope I have the opportunity to work with her again !

- Chad lewis

We've had the pleasure of working with Nicole and her team to sell and buy several properties over the last eight years. She is professional, respectful, and is an absolute expert realtor. We've recommended Nicole and her team to several friends and family over the years as well. We highly recommend Nicole and her team to any future home buyers or sellers.

- Brittni Vasila

I have been working with Nicole for over 20 years and have bought and sold homes and she always gets the job done.I would recommend her to any one looking to buy or sell a home.

- Zillow User

I could not have chosen a better realtor team to help me sell my house. I was referred by a personal friend, and Nicole far exceeded all expectations. Her and her team worked with me closely on every aspect of selling my home, and the entire process went flawlessly. My house was listed on November  1st. and the closing was done on December 11..... 41 days from start to finish! Cannot believe how easy they made the entire process for me, and that was done even with me living 1000 miles away and out of state from the house was that I was selling. I would recommend Nicole to anyone for obvious reasons, and I hope I have the opportunity to work with her again !

- Zillow User

Kathleen Hanna was the first agent to contact me from an area search for an agent to list a property in Marsyville. I live in Cincinnati and was searching somewhat blindly, but really hit the jackpot with Kathleen! She was precise and consistent with her follow-up and always very professional.   The property we needed to sell was a flipper that we sold as-is, despite the need for considerable foundation work. Kathleen guided my family through the process and patiently answered all of our questions. When referencing or describing the property, she was always diplomatic, courteous, and professional. The closing was exactly one month from the listing date! Kathleen's team has the most efficient system for organizing the listing papers that I've seen from any team: a folder portfolio with a notepad of the papers, complete with carbons for ease in keeping materials together and in sequence. I'm very impressed! Kathleen was an excellent communicator throughout the whole process. We couldn't have been more pleased!

- Zillow User

Nicole and her team do a great job! I know who I will be going to when I need to sell my house. Highly recommend!

- Alex Ribble

We needed to sell our house quickly and without hassle. The Nicole Yoder-Barnhart team did an awesome job. They walked us through the whole process and had our house up for sale quickly. They communicated well throughout the entire process and made sure we were comfortable every step of the way. Special shout-out to Nicci, she was our main contact and was always there to answer questions or talk through any issues. They made selling our house a great experience ! Would highly recommend.

- Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Columbus, OH.

Nicole helped us keep our sanity in a crazy real estate market with her expertise and her level-headed advising. We had total confidence in her experience and the knowledge she brought to the process was invaluable.

- Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Powell, OH.

Our first meeting with Nicole, she said she was going to make us homeless. She did. We did an open house the first week listed and had 2 offers that day!! Then, game on to find a new house. Nicole and her team helped us learn about buying a foreclosure and the in and outs of the experience. We  did find a house and have been in it 9 years. Nicole and her team helped our friends sell and buy a new home and most recently helped my parents sell their home. Highly recommended.

- Zillow User

The Nicole Yoder-Barnhart Team took away the stress and uncertainty of selling and buying a home. They’ve since worked with multiple friends to find their forever home. When we outgrow this home we’ll be calling them again.

- Bought and sold a Condo home in 2013 in Hilliard, OH.

Nicole and her team do a great job! I know who I will be going to when I need to sell my house. Highly recommend!

- Alex Ribble
From the moment I met Nicole, she was sharp as a tack. I interviewed multiple realtors and was impressed by her 25 year track record and tech savvy. She sold my neighbor’s house $42k above asking and felt confident we could have a similar outcome. Sitting at my dining room table during the initial interview, she produced several “what if we sell at this price” numbers with only a few taps on her phone. The report came via text showing our bottom line after all fees. That was impressive. About a week later we listed the house and held an open house. The showing traffic was unbelievable; a true parade of people. We left for that weekend and came home to 12 offers!! We narrowed them down to an all cash offer, which ended up $56,000 above asking price, along with a backup offer. Two weeks later, we closed on our home and the money was wired to our bank account within fifteen minutes of the closing. Again, impressive. 
Now some might argue that the market was the reason for the success, and it did contribute, but I believe that Nicole did many things that impacted the outcome and the higher price. I might mention up front that during this sales process, she experienced the loss of her mother and yet not a single thing fell through the crack. Her team was solid, always available and helpful during her personal tragedy. It’s hard to find the kind of service they delivered. Nicole also worked with our top offers to pull the best terms out of all the offers. This meant our buyers increased the offering price and provided better terms. Ultimately, our buyers let us rent back our home and reduced the cost of rent with her savvy negotiation. 
There was a moment early in the process where we had a change of heart about selling, totally because we feared we wouldn’t find a place to go. Nicole stayed steady and executed our decision not to sell, taking our home off the “coming soon” market and cancelling our showings. When we came back a day later and said, “We are facing the fear let’s sell,” she worked hard to line up showings once again. No one wants to do the work twice, and it feels crummy to have a seller do that, but she didn’t show a shred of negative emotion. She just did the job. 
Compared to some past experiences with realtors, I can say the interactions were straight forward, didn’t feel manipulative and exceeded my high performance standards. I highly recommend Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and her team.
- A Happy Client

Professional but friendly, results driven, quick and successful transaction. There are reasons things go good.

- William Gary

The Nicole Yoder-Barnhart team was outstanding to work with. We needed to sell our home quickly and efficiently and they did just that for us. They were super helpful throughout the process and there was never a lack in communication. We worked with Nicci specifically the most and she was so wonderful! It is nice to work with a team of people who really know what they are doing and do their jobs well. I would highly recommend if you are in need to buy or sell your property.

- Hannah Barney

- Jean M.

Nicole helped us sell our home and purchase our new one. She went above and beyond to accommodate our schedules. She explained everything throughout the process making us feel at ease at a time that can be stressful. We would highly recommend Nicole and her team.

- Jim

- Stephanie D.

Thank you Nicole! You have been so kind to me. When I didn't understand things or got scared you knew exactly what to say. It really meant a lot to me. You have helped Jack and I get everything together so that this could happen. I am not sure how you did all of this and at the same time, moved your own family. I thank the Lord, He placed you in our path. 

- Jean W.

Moving to a new city and committing to house hunt right away was exciting and daunting. Fortunately, our relocation company paired us with Nicole Yoder-Barnhart at HER Realtors. Unbeknownst to us, we landed in THE BEST hands Ohio has to offer relocation clients undertaking the home buying process.

Our connection with Nicole was immediate and genuine. As a good listener and astute observer, Nicole showed us homes that could potentially work for each of us and cautioned us not to feel pressured to settle. Nicole was responsive, knowledgeable and encouraging from the onset. Given the specificity of our wishlist and timeline Nicole helped us find the perfect home - a new build that we were able to customize to our satisfaction. To top it off-(testimony to her expansive network)- Nicole extended the invitation for a casting call to one of our favorite shows-House Hunters! We are honored and humbled to share one of the largest and most emotional decisions as homeownership and our HGTV debut with Nicole. It has all been quite the adventure and we could not have had a better captain of the home searching ship than NYB!

Consistently throughout the process, Nicole demonstrated professionalism, shared thoughtful insights and was an absolute delight to work with. So blessed to have been partnered with Nicole to successfully find our perfect home. We have come to regard her as a friend and our forever realtor!

- Summa

Nicole is extremely knowledgable about all of the areas around Columbus. She knew it was the right time for us to sell and get the top dollar we could for our home. She then helped us get into our new dream house just a few miles away!

- Jennifer

Nicole is my go-to for real estate needs. She and her team have sold our old house and my condo, found our builder for our current home, and found my parents (who live 3 hours away) a condo here in Powell. When you need someone to take care of you for real estate... she’s the one! Happy to call you my friend Nicole!

- Molly


Nicole, I wanted to say thanks and let you know what a pleasure it was to work with you and your team. It was the smoothest deal I have had and I will be hard pressed to do better.

- Chuck

I want to thank you personally for all your efforts that resulted in our being able to close. Your attention to detail coupled with your honest, straightforward and professional approach helped bring this transaction to closing. Cooperation is the foundation of SUCCESS in our industry.

- Rosetta

Just wanted to send you a quick note to say thank you for helping in getting the property in Clifton Chase sold so that they could move into their new dream home. I know they are getting more and more excited and anxious to move in and they are relieved to have their existing home sold. 

- Milka

You guys are the greatest and we can't thank you enough for all you've done for us. Thanks again, we could not have sold our house without you!

- Jay and Tracy

Congratulations on your success and national recognition as someone who is outstanding in the real estate industry. You do a great job with your clients. Congrats Again!

- Mary

Thank you so much for the effort you made in helping us buy and sell our house. We appreciate everything from making us feel like your one and only client (which we knew you had more) to treating our every question like it was not a bother. You are both tremendously good at what you do and we won't hestitate to refer you to anyone we know.

- Kenny and Jenny

I just wanted to say thanks for the great co-op. I am looking forward to working with you again, soon! 

- JP

Nicole, thank you for everything. We love our house! 

- Kevin and Gina

Nicole, I can't thank you enough for all of your professional advice over the phone the other night. You are terrific! Thank you for answering all of my questions so candidly. You gave me the confidence and information I needed to communicate more effectively with my realtor. Thank you.

- Pam

We would like you to continue to be our agent for future considerations. Out of all the agents we have been in contact with, we thank you were and are the most caring and helpful. We want to thank you for that. 

- Robert and Maria

Our property had been on the market for nearly 2 years before we signed with Nicole. She was our 4th realtor. After parting ways with the others due to (what we believe to have been) "unethical reasons," Nicole was like a breath of fresh air with her professional ethics. The real estate world would be a better place if all realtors had Nicole's personality and integrity. She is a very hard worker and she represented HER extremely well. Words could NEVER express appreciation for Nicole. She is a real gem! We highly recommend her to everyone! And we will definitely call her in the future!

- Lisa

Nicole and her team sold our home and the homes of other family members. We were very satisfied with the level of professionalism, knowledge and expertise we experienced.

- Jane

Our opinion of Nicole and her team hasn't changed in 4 years since Julie sold us our current home. Julie Barnhart found what we wanted at a fabulous price and worked with us the whole way. She felt like family! We are happy here and plan to stay the rest of our lives. Thanks, Yoder-Barnhart team!

- Ed and Gina

Nicole is very knowledgeable about all real estate needs. She helped my sell my home and buy a new one. She showed me several houses until I found the perfect one. She is a pleasure to work with and to be around. She's always professional, while wearing a smile.

- Zillow User

Understand your need, very cooperative. Help us to find good home for my family. Trusty people, local knowledge, negotiation skill, responsiveness and process expertise. Always ready to help.

- Realtor.com User

Excellent service and professionalism by Nicole. Nicole was sincere and helpful from beginning to end. Just the type of person you need when looking for your first home or which every one you are on. She was flexible with timings and availability when I requested to visit a property on the weekend. She gave us her honest view, which helped us in making informative decision. Would definitely recommend.

- Chris

Purchased a Condo in 2014 with them. The process went smoothly and the agent was responsive and assisted us in getting the information we needed to make our decision.

- Realtor.com User

The Nicole- Yoder Barnhart Team helped us buy are first house. They helped us make sure that we bought a house that we were going to be able to afford. They then sold our first house when the housing market was at its low. We decided to buy land and build a home and The Nicole Yoder Barnhart team was there to help negotiate for our land and close on our new build. if and when we sell our current home we will have their team helps us do it.We recommend them to everyone especially on people who are buying their first home. Their team is patient, hardworking and trustworthy.

- Tabby

I was given a tour of multiple homes before settling on my final purchase in Canal Winchester. I was very happy with the entire process. I appreciate her hard work and dedication to my buying needs!

- Sarah

It has been almost 3 years since we bought our home through this agency but we still feel connected and part of their real estate family. We liked Julie Barnhart the second she greeted us at the first showing. She had the energy and enthusiasm that seemed to be lacking in previous agents from other agencies. Anyway, if we ever sell or know of a friend who wants to sell or buy, Julie would be the first person we contact.

As far as feeling connected is concerned, the Yoder-Barnhart team keeps us informed with email newsletters and the annual invitation to a movie event. This year we will be attending and bringing our 9 year-old daughter whom we will be adopting in the spring. Again, it is always a comfort knowing we have the support and friendship of the Yoder-Barnhart team!

- Ed and Gina

I would highly recommend Nicole and her team. We used them as both buyer and sellers agents several years ago and have recommended to others several times since. They have also been helpful over the years when I have had a general real estate question for myself and family members. I will not hesitate to use them again if the need arises.

- John

The Yoder-Barnhart Team have helped my family sell and purchase homes more than once. Their Motto should be we're not happy if you aren't happy.
People don't stay in homes for ever like in the past. So repeat customers are what makes a business successful. This team has always gone out of the way to help us make the best decisions when it comes to selling or purchasing a home.

- Realtor.com User

The Yoder-Barnhart team is amazing! Extremely responsive and professional. They truly have been a source of knowledge during this process and have really cared about my needs in a property. They have worked tirelessly for me and my family and I'm so thankful for them.

- Realtor.com User

I never take the time to fill out Review's but for Nicole and her team I wanted to do this. I've used Nicole for more than one Purchase for me and my family. I have referred several people to her and they all have nothing but great things to say. Not only is Nicole the very best Realtor in Ohio she's also the nicest and most genuine person I've ever met. I know Nicole has my best interest at heart and will continue to use her for all my real-estate needs.

- Realtor.com User

I would highly recommend Nicole and her team! We were relocating from Florida to Ohio and relied greatly on her team to help us with our search. When we found a home we were interested in one of her team members were always available to go preview the home for us, take the time to facetime us so we could also view the home remotely and answer our multiple questions on the homes. Upon going into contract they were extremely helpful with us being so far away from working with our lender who was also in Ohio, explaining all phases of the contract process(home inspection, appraisal, warranties available, closing process etc). They helped make a very stressful move much less stressful and I highly recommend them!

- Sharon

The Yoder-Barnhart Team is excellent to work with from start to finish. They immediate provide you with "comparables" and help you determine a price that will sell your home but also factor in your goals. I had a great experience as my home sold two days after being listed. I would highly recommend the Yoder-Barnhart Team as they are very professional, responsive and also very caring about helping you whether it be the sale of your home or finding the home that is perfect for you.

- Richard

We worked with Nicole Yoder-Barnhart and her team on a new build. She was great to work with, extremely knowledgeable made for a stress free transition into our new home!!

- Jayson

We had a wonderful experience working with Nicole and her team. She sold our house quickly and got a great price. If we ever move again, we will most definitely work with Nicole!

- Becky

Nicole is very professional and one of the top agents in the area. She coordinated each showing and made the entire experience painless. I would have no problem using her services again.

- Howard

Nicole and her team is outstanding. Their knowledge is second to none. She had our house sold in 8 days of being on the market a few years back. Since then we have referred Nicole and her team to many of our friends and clients. Everyone always thanks us for getting them in touch with her. She is and always will be our realtor of choice. If you are selling a home, buying a home or relocating, I highly recommend using Nicole Yoder-Barnhart for any of your real estate needs.

- Randy

The Yoder-Barnhart Team is excellent to work with, they have the experience and the expertise to assist with any and all real estate needs. I recommend them to all of my clients/acquaintances when they have a real estate need. They do a great job helping you with the valuation and marketing of your home, so that you get the most from the sale of your home!! They helped a mutual client sell a rental home.

- Ricki

While I normally dont write reviews until I have purchased a product, I felt the need to do so in this case. Nicole and her team is truly top notch. Within a very short time of reaching out to them, I was contacted back after work hours. I didnt expect a call until the next day. She was able to immediately set me up on a search and review situation to make sure i am fully ready to go. We have been on several showings at the drop of a hat. In our market currently homes are flying off the shelf and its a sellers market for sure. Having Nicole has truly given me a leg up on other buyers and I am confident i will be in contract soon. If you are going to choose a real estate agent, choose Nicole!!

- John

We originally planned to list our home with another realtor since we knew him from our neighborhood, however, due to requirements by our relocation company, we met with an additional two realtors, and one of those was Nicole. We were so impressed by her, that we immediately decided that she was the agent for us. And, did she ever deliver!! We had about 10 showings the very first weekend, received three offers, two which were full-price, and were in contract after the first weekend. She listed our home for a higher amount than the original realtor, and assured us that it would sell the first weekend. She was absolutely right! We would highly recommend Nicole for anyone interested in selling their home!

- Realtor.com User

Nicole is top notch. Not many realtors provide the level of service I get from Nicole and HER. She's sells 200+ houses a year. I've referred friends and family and she's helped everyone accomplish their goals between buying and selling. Anytime I need to see a new MLS listing, she's on it getting my wife and I in the house promptly. I'm picky and hard to please, but Nicole continues to put up with me. I would highly recommend Nicole to any buyer, from a novice to any old pro. Put her to the test, she'll get things done for you too!

- Michael

During this whole process they really work with you. I like the fact you were educated about certain homes if they had previous issues. The team was very helpful and prompt with showings. If I were to do it all over again I would definitely choose Nicole Yoder-Barnhart team

- Keshia

Nicole and Sharon sold our condo during the WORST market conditions. Sharon spent so much time with us and was so patient in helping us to find the right house. We had to back out of one at the last minute due to mold and find something else quickly, and she made it work, got us our earnest money back, and got us in to the right house for us in record time! Lori Love is also exceptional, the whole team was fantastic for us and if we ever move again we will absolutely call Sharon/Nicole first.

- Realtor.com User

I worked with Nicole and Kathleen in 2007 when I moved from Scottsdale, Arizona. They were very professional and a delight to work with. They both had many years of experience and were very knowledgeable about the home buying process.
Although my situation changed and I had to move further north to Alliance, OH due to family concerns, I look forward to working with them in the future and highly recommend them to anyone who is thinking about buying or selling a home.

- Cindy

When we started looking for a home it was in Janurary 2011. We didn't know the first thing about it but a friend said check out Nicole Barnhart Team with Her. So we called. We talked with Lori and she helpped get the ball rolling. She took our applacation and put us in contact with Brenee. Anytime weneeded anything on the phone or at the office everyone was very nice and helpful. We told them what we wanted in our dream home. Where we wanted to live . After setting up appointment with Lori and Brenee we found out our financing and then went looking on thier website. Then we would go out and look at homes with Brenee. If we didn't find one Brenee would cheer us up by saying you will know it when you see it and it will feel like home. On March 9th we found Our dream home. It was eveything we wanted and more. We were so excitied . On April 22,2011 we signed the papers on OUR DREAM HOME !!! We just spent our First Holiday Season at our home. It was fantastic. Our families and friends all love it and are so happy for us !! I would recomend Nicole and Her Team to anyone and everyone I know. Thanks Nicole , Lori, Brenee and the rest of the Barnhart team for all you did and do to make dreams come true. You made ours come true !!!

- Realtor.com User

Add A Testimonial

Would you like to add a testimonial about your great experience? Use this fast and easy form to send us your comments and feedback.